fairandcold

I think Simon can be an asshole, but overall, he's just telling the truth. I like his judgements. Does anybody have a fave wannabe American Idol??

Dejonay

I have only watched bits of it, but i stopped watching it recently because of that English Judge Simon. He is so mean, ok everyones allowed their opinion but he just goes way over the top!
De
xxxxxxxxxx

JessieG

I really like that show, but it sucks that I can't vote since I'm in Canada.

Dejonay

I just cant stand simon, he's been out in the sun to long because hes very red and his voice is just as annoying as some of the contestants he couldnt sing!!!

Meighan

My favourite contestant overall is Justin AKA Fro-Boy. He's amazing! I mean, come on! How many people can make Paula Abdule cry on national TV!?!

Suzie

omg, Justin is like.....omg, yes he's my favorite. I agree with Ta-mi-ka when she said he could sing her the phonebook and she'd be happy. I really really hope he wins! And if not, you know that because he's so talented he'll go on to better things. I love Kelly Clarkson too, she was really good.

I love Simon!! Probably because I usually agree with him and he's been wayyy nicer lately. I think that...yeah, he says some mean things but he still has a sense of humor about it all. Plus it's not like he doesn't feel bad about it, he even said himself that sometimes he watches the shows after and is like 'oh god, why did i say that?'

RY-MAN

i luv that show but i can't pick a fav and i can't wait till the FINAL EPISODE WHEN THE WINNER OF POP IDOL (THE UK VERSION OF AMERICAN IDOL ) (WILL YOUNG) PERFORMS!!!!!!!!!!!